| No. | Result | Record | Opponent | Type | Round, time | Date | Location | Notes |
|---|
| 51 | Loss | 31–6–10 (4) | Steve O'Donnell | TKO | 5 (15), 2:15 | Oct 20, 1899 | Germania Maennerchor Hall, Baltimore, Maryland, US |
| 50 | Loss | 31–5–10 (4) | Frank Slavin | KO | 1 (10), 2:15 | Sep 14, 1896 | Eureka A.C., Baltimore, Maryland, US |
| 49 | ND | 31–4–10 (4) | Abe Ullman | ND | 10 | Sep 30, 1895 | Baltimore, Maryland, US | Exact date unknown |
| 48 | Loss | 31–4–10 (3) | Steve O'Donnell | TKO | 21 (25), 1:18 | May 6, 1895 | Sea Side A.C., Coney Island, New York, US |
| 47 | Draw | 31–3–10 (3) | Steve O'Donnell | PTS | 8 | Mar 18, 1895 | Suffolk A.C., Boston, Massachusetts, US |
| 46 | Loss | 31–3–9 (3) | Frank Slavin | TKO | 9 (10) | Jun 16, 1891 | Granite A.C., Hoboken, New Jersey, US | For world interim heavyweight title (National Police Gazette)[6] |
| 45 | Win | 31–2–9 (3) | George Godfrey | KO | 44 | Mar 13, 1891 | California A.C., San Francisco, California, US | A finish fi
|